About

Committed to
Earning your business

Our agency is committed to doing the right thing, for the right people, for the right reasons. We know that there are many people competing for your attention. We want to EARN your business by regularly reviewing your coverage, and helping you receive the best value all while maintaining an actual neighbor to neighbor relationship.

All of your insurance needs provided by a local, friendly, and expert staff. At Deiwert Insurance we strive to be the absolute best people we can be. That is an ever moving and evolving vision of ourselves. We know that if we focus on improving our ability to listen and communicate, then the relationships we build with our customers will be real and long lasting. A long lasting genuine relationship serves our customers and ultimately gives us a purpose far beyond a sale. We want to know and serve our community and providing quality insurance coverage with you as our primary focus is how we do that.

Deiwert Insurance has been a local family owned and operated business for 30 years. Our father son team prides itself in quality customer service, and personal access to insurance experts. Honesty, integrity, and a true passion for people are three reasons you should give Deiwert Insurance the chance to earn your business.

About sam

Sam and his wife Debbie established Deiwert Insurance Agency in 1991 after twenty three years as a community banking executive. Married since 1968, they’ve built a life together rooted in family, raising 4 children along the way. Sam has extensive experience with finance, real estate, and community development. Sam was Mayor of Delphi for eight years and the experience gained during this period of service along with his years of work in finance and real estate brings a wide breadth of life skills to the customers of Deiwert Insurance Agency.  Sam is a beekeeper and works on restoration of a family farmstead that has been in his family since 1832.

About PETE & Crystal

Peter joined the Air Force in 2002 where he proudly served four years including two tours of duty in Iraq. After his service he worked for the Department of Defense and in July of 2008 joined his father at Deiwert Insurance. Peter married Crystal in 2009 and Crystal joined the agency in 2012.  Peter quickly become proficient in both commercial and personal insurance. He loves the challenge of analyzing risk and creating the best protection for his customers.  Crystal oversees the day-to-day operations and supporting the agency’s team.  Pete & Crystal enjoy mountain biking, backpacking and are overall outdoor enthusiasts. 

Meet Our team

Lauren Biddle

Senior Account Agent

Lauren Biddle joined the Deiwert Agency in 2013. As our Senior Account Agent Lauren continues to personally service her customers with the care and dedication that she built her reputation on as she builds and cultivates new business.

Lauren knows no stranger and loves meeting new people! Her customers truly are an extension of her family.

Lauren was born and raised in Indianapolis and now hails from the BIG CITY of Pine Village! Lauren is married to Casey. Together, they have a son, Charlie, and she is a bonus Mom to Casey’s daughter, Hunter. When Lauren isn’t working you can find her in Indy spending time with her family, camping or at a sporting event for one of the kids!

Jordan Shirk

Account Executive

Jordan found her home at the Deiwert Agency in 2015.  She brings more than 15 years of insurance industry experience starting in customer service and advancing to become a trusted advisor to clients across personal, commercial and life lines.

Known for client-first approach shaped by her years of firsthand service experience, Jordan combines technical insurance knowledge with genuine relationship-building skills.

Away from the office, Jordan enjoys spending time with her husband, KC and her two children, Xander and Piper. Gardening, being outdoors and crafting are some of her favorite activities.

Sadie Pennington

Customer Service

Sadie entered the world of insurance in 2026 with the Deiwert Agency. Having been a Deiwert customer for nearly 10 years, she was excited to be able to serve her community with a company she trusts.

Sadie and her husband enjoy spending time on their property in Carroll County with dogs, cats, and kids.

Personal attention

When you call, you will receive the personal attention that you want. You are a valued customer, not an “account number.” You are a familiar face, a valued friend, and a neighbor. We will be there for you when you need us most!

Superior claim service

In the event of a loss, you can count on us to be there for you. We stand ready to follow through on the entire process, making sure that everything goes right. We want to partner with you to make sure you never feel alone at a difficult time in your life.

Refer a friend

As an insurance professional I have found that generating new business can be a daunting task. When I began this agency I quickly realized that regardless of what our marketing efforts were, the bulk of my business still continued to come straight from our existing clients referrals. So, we learned early on, that in order for us to maintain a consistent flow of business, we would need to focus our attention on building our current client referral base. One of the best ways we can ensure that this will happen is to rely on the relationships we already have with our existing clients—people like you.

Hopefully, we have done our job well enough that you might be prompted, when the time is right, to recommend our services to someone else that needs the service and pricing we offer. Nothing says “thank you” more than having a person who has a need for our services call us, because of the recommendation you made. We really appreciate and value the relationship we have with our clients and it is priceless to have a relationship that is strong enough for you to recommend our services to others. Because these individuals trust you, the likelihood that they will trust us increases substantially. We understand that you have also put a great deal of trust in us and I will ensure that these referrals get the very best we have to offer.

It is important that we point out that it is not your responsibility to help us grow our business. It is our responsibility to maintain and develop a relationship with you that will be strong enough that you might feel motivated to recommend us whenever the opportunity presents itself in the future. I am truly grateful for each time you recommend this agency.

Sincerely,
Sam Deiwert

Pay bill online

File a claim

get a quote

Online solutions

to take action

Are you looking to pay your bill? File a claim? Request a quote? We know "life" usually happens outside of the hours of 9 to 5. That's why for your convenience, you can contact us anytime of the day online for your insurance needs!